The world of cinema has witnessed a recent surge in adaptations of Shakespeare's Hamlet, with Scarlet joining the ranks. However, this anime interpretation by Mamoru Hosoda, a renowned director, falls short of expectations, leaving viewers with a sense of dissatisfaction.
What makes Scarlet particularly intriguing is its bold departure from the traditional Hamlet narrative. Hosoda begins with a twist, presenting an exploitation-style introduction to the characters of Claudius and Gertrude, who openly discuss their murderous intentions. This sets the stage for a unique retelling, but the execution falters.
The film's netherworld, a purgatory-like realm, feels hastily constructed. The presence of Claudius and his minions in this realm is unexplained, and the introduction of a lightning-spewing leviathan adds an element of convenience rather than coherence. Additionally, the character of Hijiri, a pacifist paramedic, serves as a mouthpiece for Hosoda's philosophical musings, which, while intriguing, lack the depth and subtlety seen in his previous works.
One aspect that truly shines in Scarlet is its animation. The 3D-augmented characters, with their imposing stature and sharp features, are a visual treat. The contrast between the immaculate sands and the near-photorealistic rubble creates a unique and captivating aesthetic. However, the inconsistent use of 2D animation in the Elsinore sections is a glaring flaw, leaving viewers questioning the stylistic choices made.
In my opinion, Scarlet's failure lies in its inability to capture the lyrical essence of Shakespearean humanism. The film's philosophical inquiries, such as "What is it to die?", feel superficial and lack the depth and complexity that define Shakespeare's works. Despite its impressive animation, Scarlet struggles to rise above its incoherent narrative and overbearing fantasy elements.
As an anime enthusiast and a lover of Shakespearean drama, Scarlet left me wanting more. While Hosoda's previous works have showcased his ability to create captivating alternative realms, Scarlet feels like a missed opportunity. The film's potential is evident in its stunning visuals, but the narrative fails to deliver a satisfying and coherent experience. Perhaps Hosoda's next venture will redeem his reputation as a leading light in the anime industry.
